adMonitor

GoogleClick – Who owns your cash register?

April 16th, 2007   |   by Frank Addante

Since Google’s announcement of their decision to acquire DoubleClick for $3.1 billion on Friday, I have received a flood of emails asking for my thoughts on the topic. So, I am going to interrupt my previous series/postings on product development to share my thoughts.

Back in 1998, DoubleClick was my #1 competitor at L90. Our product, adMonitor, was a direct competitor to DoubleClick’s ad serving technology. When we started, we were the 7th horse in a 7 horse race. DoubleClick, like other competitors, had already underwent a successful IPO and their market cap was in the billions and their resources were virtually unlimited. Against the odds, within a few years, adMonitor had become one of the most dominant advertising networks on the Internet, serving billions of ads each month for over 3,000 companies such as Microsoft, AT&T and Visa. Ultimately, we gave DoubleClick a run for their money and shortly after we took L90 public, DoubleClick acquired adMonitor to take us out of the market. A move very similar to what Google is doing with DoubleClick today.

Recently, I have been looking very closely at the online advertising market. I was shocked to see how little has changed in the past 7 years. The online advertising market was hot 7 years ago, it tanked during the dot-com fall out and recently (a few years ago, along with Google’s IPO) has become hot again. Google is clearly the driving force behind its success. And, it has become clear to me why. Google was the only real technology innovation in the online advertising market. Google made it simple. (see my posting on “Keep it Simple“)

Google has cornered the online advertising market. Prior to Google, the online advertising market ran like the stock market without a NASDAQ computer. Everything was manual (shifting around excel spreadsheets) and there was little visibility available to advertisers and little exposure available for publishers. Google simply came in and automated it.

Most of the online advertising space today is made up of broker-dealers. I believe this to be the case because there is still a lack of technology in the space. There is some new technology, but mostly very specific, niche technology solutions such as video ad-servers, behavioral targeting, etc. Aside from these micro-innovations, the only other real innovation in the space are the advertising marketplaces where advertisers can purchase advertising from mid-tier publishers through an automated system.

Google is the dominant player because they have technology. Drawing an analogy from the online advertising business to the coffee business… It’s like Coffee Bean, Peet’s Coffee and other competitors leasing their cash registers and coffee machines from Starbucks. Many of Google’s closest competitors are using Google’s adserving technology to drive advertising revenue. Great for Google, bad for everyone else.

I am not the least bit surprised that DoubleClick sold for $3.1 billion. Personally, I think it was the smartest decision Google could have made. What’s the cost of not having it? What if there was another competitive cash register on the market? DoubleClick’s technology, while old and antiquated, was the only other decent “cash register” with any traction. Sure, there’s a wave of new technology solutions that have come into the market that are competitive with DoubleClick, but, they are unproven. Most of these new companies have been started by “newbies” to the advertising space and it’s going to take them a while to learn the advertising business. Most of the veterans from the first online advertising revolution 7-10 years ago are likely sitting on yachts counting their payouts.

So, now the large networks are revolting against the GoogleClick deal. They are challenging the deal with the government on anti-trust claims, saying that it gives Google too much power and they will have an unfair advantage. I think this is a bunch of nonsense. Sure, Google has a significant advantage, but I don’t believe they have an unfair one. They just happen to be the main supplier of cash registers and coffee machines. Anyway, come on, Google’s mantra is “don’t be evil”, right? How could they abuse their power? Besides, with Google trying to launch satellites, building mobile phones, trying to replace Microsoft Office, scanning libraries of books, who has time for advertising technology anyway?

However, make no mistake about it, Google is very much a competitor to any publisher. They have one of the largest websites on the Internet and that is their main business. They keep 100% of the revenue from their own website and only a fraction when selling advertising on other sites. There needs to be another supplier of cash registers and coffee machines and there is nothing preventing another supplier from entering the market. However, the problem with it is that it is damn hard to build advertising technology. It took us years at L90/adMonitor, hundreds of billions of ad impressions worth of learning, millions of dollars and hundreds of people to get it right… It’s not impossible, it’s just hard, time consuming and expensive. The GoogleClick deal doesn’t prevent anyone from competing, it just sets everyone else back another 12-18 months further than they were before.

Smart move on Google’s part and congratulations to the geniuses at the private equity firms (Hellman & Friedman and JMI Equity) that identified this hole in the market and bought DoubleClick for a fraction of what they sold it for. But, if I were a publisher or a major network using anything from GoogleClick, I’d want to find another supplier of cash registers and coffee machines before someone drives up my rental fee or takes my cash register away (with my customer list and cash still in the drawer). Ahh, maybe I’m just being paranoid… If I’m a publisher using Google, they already have my customer list, advertising data and revenue information anyway…

After writing this, I think I smell something… I can’t tell if it’s a fresh pot of coffee or Startup 6.0 brewing…

(For the record, I don’t drink coffee.)



  • alibaba trade manager client download
  • christina milian am to pm download free mp3
  • borderlands modded character download
  • adrian minune omul norocos download
  • aborting video microsoft codec download page
  • bethel live dvd download
  • brenda lee sweet nothings download free
  • bharat sharma vyas songs download
  • ceramic destroyer game download
  • buddha bar music download
  • a r rahman vande mataram video download
  • busybox android download to pc
  • buzzer beat ep 7 download
  • champaign shower lmfao download
  • cartella download windows explorer
  • asus n16 manual download
  • catan aˆ“ stA¤dte & ritter download
  • apostila direito constitucional download gratis
  • 3com 3c905 tx driver download windows 7
  • baki b3 zovi mp3 download
  • brincar com o fogo download
  • busybox download to pc
  • baby giggle ringtone download
  • animacje do gothic multiplayer download
  • acrobat reader full download
  • astral projection i doser download
  • boski A?igolo lektor pl download
  • bibi blocksberg staffel 1 download
  • adat shadmehr download mp3
  • canon c300 driver download
  • ain't no way mp3 download
  • 100 ?????»?° ?»??Nˆ?° mp3 download
  • apparat album 2011 download
  • activar modo download samsung galaxy s2
  • baixar filme homem aranha 4 download
  • anonymous os x download
  • angel haze download mp3
  • audio book kindle download
  • asus o'play air firmware download
  • blessings laura story free download mp3
  • bio medical books free download
  • asus p5vdc mx drivers download for xp
  • apics dictionary 13th edition download
  • antes que termine download dublado
  • aAYk yeniden mp3 download
  • atozmp3 telugu free download songs
  • bewafai album songs download free 2010
  • celine dion mp3 free download
  • asus p5n e sli manual download
  • brush download illustrator cs5
  • ambani telugu songs download
  • anya your voice download zippy
  • capella reader mac download
  • android lock ipad download
  • anatomy of reanimation blitzkid download
  • age de glace 4 download fr
  • besplatna muzika za download mp3
  • buffy l'ammazzavampiri stagione 5 download
  • chennai 60028 songs download 123musiq
  • cd dvd druckerei 7 download crack
  • andala rakshasi songs download 320kbps
  • cassia eller para download
  • aarti om jai jagdish download free
  • alejandro dave aude remix download
  • bonus rpk dwie wiadomoA›ci download
  • autoroute freeware kostenlos download
  • cds de vaquejada para download
  • business plan pro download and crack
  • authentec fingerprint software download windows 7
  • 20 poucos anos download
  • andrea bocelli download romanza
  • astral projection burning up download
  • chilly cha cha music download
  • acero puro hd download
  • caA§adores de emoA§Aµes download legendado
  • attitude student's book 3 download
  • adobe acrobat x pro download portable
  • canon sx1 firmware download
  • addictive drums fl studio download
  • bank gothic download for free
  • 7.62 high calibre game download
  • battle realm 2 download
  • android lock iphone download free
  • carbide.ui symbian theme editor 4.0 download
  • ambiance a l'africaine free mp3 download
  • ahmet kaya yemen tA?rkA?sA? download
  • badrinath south mp3 download
  • cam hack download v1.2
  • acer aspire 7730 software download
  • chama negra download tenses
  • blackberry gps software download
  • 2A—17 know thy enemy download
  • club dogo download album gratis
  • castellan fisico quimica download portugues
  • cant download bully xbox 360
  • anabela ne zovi me download
  • cliq xt recovery image download
  • canon mp560 treiber download mac
  • canon mx300 driver download windows xp
  • che la luna mp3 download
  • britain's got talent 2008 download
  • bo wodke trzeba pic download mp3
  • arial mt extra bold download
  • camel in action source code download
  • aplikacije za lg p350 download
  • apocalyptica noten kostenlos download
  • caramelldansen download english version
  • canon mx 320 download driver
  • alien vs predator 1 download full
  • chibi vampire vol 6 download
  • canon lbp 3000 software download
  • cinematic orchestra ma fleur download free
  • addison groove bad things download
  • accenture office communicator download
  • brother mfl pro suite mfc 290c download
  • acrobat x pro trial download for mac
  • anas younus free mp3 download
  • canon lbp 3000 driver download winxp
  • a usurpadora download dublado rmvb
  • 38 spec no more download
  • businessplan kostenlos download excel
  • brokencyde dying to live download
  • cartman poker face download
  • barA?o de munchausen download livro
  • autocad structural detailing 2011 download
  • apple airplay utility download
  • arcade fire sprawl soulwax download
  • atmosphere keep steppin mp3 download
  • almanaque abril download gratis
  • bully scholarship edition zip download
  • broadcom 802 11b g driver download
  • a riqueza das naA§Aµes download mcconnell
  • ant smasher download para celular
  • akhiyan nu rehn de mp3 free download
  • alice maciel musicas download
  • amigo fura olho download mp3
  • cancion del mariachi download mp3
  • btoes 2.0 x micro driver download
  • band master complete download
  • achtung die ecke download
  • call of juarez 1 download full game
  • battlefield 3 reloaded free download
  • christmas carols english download
  • alicia a natale puoi download gratis
  • business plan template download word
  • appalaraju songs free download from southmp3
  • businessman sir osthara mp3 download
  • 4shared download kotak kecuali kamu
  • canon pixma mg3150 driver download
  • buika el ultimo dragon download free
  • apostila do stm para download